Readers only offer: Get additional Rs 200 off on 'The Better Home' powerful natural cleaners. Shop Now
Meet the Indian Woman Who Stood up to Trump, 5 Years Before Hillary Did

Meet the Indian Woman Who Stood up to Trump, 5 Years Before Hillary Did

Five years before the US presidential candidate Hilary Clinton faced off against Donald Trump, an Indian woman had showed the courage to stand up to him.

Smita Panvalkar, the then 54-year-old resident of an 87-year-old building in Mumbai stood fiercely between Trump and his dream to enter the Indian real estate market.


Image for representation only. Source: Pixabay

Back in 2011, Donald Trump had teamed up with a local developer to construct ‘Trump Tower’, a 65-storey building that was supposed to house some 50 ultra-luxury apartments in Mumbai. According to a BBC report, the developer had even forged a branding agreement with him stating that he would use the Trump brand name in exchange for royalties.

The site chosen for the project was the Pathare Prabhu Building in the posh south Mumbai neighbourhood of Chowpatty. It was home to 25 tenant families, the Panvalkars being one of them. Two more plots adjacent to the building were purchased for the same project.

You may also like: MY VIEW: Trump or Clinton – Which President Should Indians be Rooting For In the US Elections

The tenants were informed about the plan in 2004 and a majority of them agreed to move. “Nothing happened until 2010. Then the developers came and informed us to vacate the building so that they could develop it,” Mr Panvalkar told BBC.

Smita, taking a lead on the subject, refused to leave their three-room apartment.

“The developers offered compensation money and asked us to vacate the apartment. Smita told them we won’t leave the building unless they gave us an apartment in the new building. Much later we learnt that the building was named after Donald Trump, the famous American tycoon,” he said.

While all the other tenants had given in, the Panvalkar family didn’t move. Even after a small fire triggered by a short circuit resulted in a 45-day power outage in the building, Smita didn’t budge. She would cook food and do her chores in the candle light. As there was no electricity, the diabetic woman also had to go without her medicines for that period.

The local press found a hero in her. There were reports praising her as ‘woman who won’t let Donald Trump Mumbai’.

For the years that followed, the Panvalkars continued to live in the same building while the planned luxury tower also faced some issues with approvals. Trump eventually moved on and his company signed agreements with Lodha Group in Mumbai and Panchshil Group in Pune in 2013 and 2014 respectively, to develop two luxury residential buildings.

This ensured victory for Smita. Soon after the family finally breathed a sigh of relief, Smita lost her life due to a massive heart attack. In April, the Panvalkar finally moved out but not without getting what Smita had insisted on. In the 22-storey building that is coming up on the plot, the family will get a flat.

Featured image credit: BBC

Like this story? Or have something to share? Write to us:, or connect with us on Facebook and Twitter.
NEW: Click here to get positive news on WhatsApp!

Let’s be friends :)
Sign in to get free benefits
  • Get positive news daily on email
  • Join our community of positive ambassadors
  • Become a part of the positive movement
Before you go...

We have a favor to ask.

Our teams put in a lot of effort to create the content you love at The Better India.

The Better Home is a range of safe and eco-friendly home cleaners by The Better India. We put out curated content on our Instagram account- green living hacks, green innovations, leading a no-tox life and heroes in the sustainability space.

It would help us if you can follow our Instagram handle and spread the word around.